Title or Question
Describe the item or answer the question so that site visitors who are interested get more information. You can emphasize this text with bullets, italics or bold, and add links.ButtonTitle or Question
Describe the item or answer the question so that site visitors who are interested get more information. You can emphasize this text with bullets, italics or bold, and add links.ButtonTitle or Question
Describe the item or answer the question so that site visitors who are interested get more information. You can emphasize this text with bullets, italics or bold, and add links.Button
How do you write about the most difficult thing you have walked through in your professional life? This is what I am going to attempt to do as I reboot the Leadership Clubhouse. I started The Leadership Clubhouse to offer encouragement and insight to other leaders after my two decades of leading in churches. But in the summer of 2024 I entered into the most difficult season of my professional life. Eventually I stopped writing for The Leadership Clubhouse, because I began to doubt that I had anything to offer any leader as the church I served was thrown into chaos and confusion. The kind of situation that, if I am being honest with you, I thought lesser leaders found themselves in. I faced accusations and attacks from members in my church. People that I had being ministering with and to for close to a decade turned against me in what felt like an overnight flip of the switch. The church felt deeply divided between those who wanted to support me and those who wanted to destroy me. It felt so uncomfortable and kind of shameful. I had always assumed that good pastors didn’t allow situations like this to develop. Our lay leaders wrestled with how to move forward. How to support their pastor, speak truth to lies, but also be peacekeepers between these two different factions that had developed. I didn’t envy the situation they found themselves in by any means. This was not the dream, not the vision, not the hope I had for the church. I was shattered and the church was shattered.
The stress landed me in the hospital with a bowel obstruction in September of that year. I began to wonder to myself, at what point do I need to walk away when the personal attacks are affecting my physical health. Do you ever walk away? I mean, look at what Jesus went through for us. Was I going to let one hospitalization cause me to walk away from the church.
Why was I going to stay? The future was uncertain. Fear was rampant. Was there something else I could do to support my family? Was I done with ministry? I felt empty as far as having anything left to offer anyone as a pastor. I felt like a failure and man is that a haunting feeling.
Eventually there was an opportunity that came along that gave us hope. Kristi had just recently started a new job and our youngest was graduating high school in June of 2025 and preparing to attend Corban University in Salem in the fall so moving was really not on the table. Not that they wouldn’t have understood but I was determined to not uproot my family again. So this opportunity was a unique blend of location, purpose and timing. As much as our leadership at Salt Creek had sought to bring peace and restoration within the church the hurt I was carrying was immense and I needed healing. Sometimes when you are a leader in the Kingdom of God you have to step back from the front lines and do some reflection, healing, and restoration in your own life. That’s where I was at.
This opportunity we found would allow me to do just that. So in July of 2025 I joined the staff of Emmanuel Bible Church in Salem as their Administrator. I was able to continue to serve in ministry just not with the same level of pressure and responsibility. In the future I will write more about this and the lessons I have been learning in this new role but for this article I am seeking to acknowledge the experience of having a ministry fall apart around you as the leader.
Here are four lessons I learned from having a ministry shattered and broken:
1. As a pastor the success of your church does not solely rise and fall on your shoulders. I believe one of the misperceptions that was born out of the church growth movement of the 80s and 90s was that everything rises and falls on one leader. This idea comes from the corporate world and doesn’t belong in pastoral theology or ecclesiology. The New Testament speaks of concepts such as the Elders of the Church, the Spiritual Gifts of every believer, the various roles in the Body of Christ, the necessity of each person in their role, and the priesthood of believers. As someone who came up in ministry on the heels of the popularity of the likes of Rick Warren and Bill Hybels, I was unduly influenced in my understanding of leadership. I created unrealistic expectations for myself and my church. I bought into the lie that if I could be enough my church would be successful and grow. The reality is that for sustained long term healthy church growth it takes mature Elders and leaders throughout the church.
2. You are more than your ministry and more than your title. I always knew this to be true and I thought that I lived my life based on this truth, but once I stepped away from the role and title of Lead Pastor only then did I realize how much it shaped who I was. I had to rediscover God’s Word for me not just for my church. I had to admit that I found self-worth in the position and title. That I liked being referred to as Pastor David. Now that the role and title is gone am I any less than I was? Nope. My role in the kingdom may have changed but my gifting and heart are still the same. So remember that you bring so much more to the table than your role and your title.
3. Listen to the voices of those who love the real you not just the professional you. One of the most disorienting things about pastoral ministry is knowing who you can and who you cannot trust. People want to know their pastor, but for some of them they want you to be their idea of their pastor and not your true self. There are those who know the true you and love you just as you are. Those are the voices you have to tune your heart to. My counselor was a huge blessing in this season as well as other pastors who knew me well. I would not have survived that season had I not listened to the voice of my wife. I am a firm believer that God gifts our spouse to be exactly the person we need as a covenant partner. Her ability to speak truth into a situation when I was doubting myself and what was and wasn’t true gave me strength when I had none.
4. God is not done writing your story. What may feel like a failure to you is never a failure in God’s eyes. God is still at work in your story. He is redeeming your mistakes and he is healing your wounds. I don’t know what your season of being shattered looks like. Was it personal sin, professional failure, physical illness? No matter what cast you into a season of life an ministry feeling shattered I can confidently tell you that God is not done writing your story. “We know that all things work together for the good of those who love God, who are called according to his purpose.” – Romans 8:28 CSB. The story may not look how you thought it would look but thanks to God’s sovereign wisdom it will look better than you could imagine
More leadership insights










